Migration Guide

Square to PayPal

Step-by-step guide to migrate from Square to PayPal in 2026. Everything you need for a smooth switch.

Hard difficultyPT8H6 steps

Quick Answer

How to migrate from Square to PayPal: Hard difficulty, PT8H, 6 steps. Migrating from Square to PayPal is a significant transition in the finance space.

Overview

Migrating from Square to PayPal is a significant transition in the finance space. This guide covers every step of the process, from exporting your Square data to getting your team fully productive in PayPal. Whether you're switching for better features, pricing, or team fit, a well-planned migration minimizes disruption.

Before You Start

Before starting your migration, audit your Square usage thoroughly. Document active projects, key integrations, custom configurations, and team workflows. Clean up unused data to keep your PayPal workspace organized from day one. Notify your team at least a week in advance and designate migration leads for each department.

How to Migrate from Square to PayPal

1

Export data from Square

PT30M

Use Square's built-in export tools to download your data. Most platforms offer CSV, JSON, or API-based export options.

2

Set up your PayPal account

PT30M

Create your PayPal workspace, configure settings, and set up the organizational structure to mirror your current setup.

3

Map features and data fields

PT30M

Review how Square concepts translate to PayPal. Document the mapping for custom fields, statuses, and workflows.

4

Import data into PayPal

PT45M

Use PayPal's import tools, CSV upload, or a third-party migration service to bring your data from Square.

5

Recreate automations and integrations

PT45M

Review your Square automations, integrations, and custom workflows. Rebuild them using PayPal's native automation features.

6

Verify data and train your team

PT30M

Check that all critical data transferred correctly. Provide training sessions and documentation to help your team adjust to PayPal.

Feature Mapping: Square vs PayPal

FeatureSquarePayPal
PaymentsSquare PaymentsPayPal Payments
InvoicingSquare InvoicingPayPal Invoicing
SubscriptionsSquare SubscriptionsPayPal Subscriptions
ReportsSquare ReportsPayPal Reports
APIsSquare APIsPayPal APIs

Data Transfer Checklist

Transfers successfully

  • Transaction history
  • Customer records
  • Invoice data
  • Product catalog

Needs manual work

  • Custom checkout flows
  • Webhook configurations
  • Reporting dashboards
  • Dispute resolution history

After Migration

After migrating, keep Square accessible for at least 30 days as a reference. Monitor team adoption and gather feedback on the PayPal experience. Set up a dedicated help channel for migration questions. Track key productivity metrics to ensure the switch is successful.

Our Verdict

The migration from Square to PayPal is complex but worthwhile with professional guidance. The biggest factor in a successful switch is thorough preparation and giving your team adequate time to adjust to the new platform.

Square to PayPal Migration FAQ

A typical migration takes 1-2 days for the technical setup. Larger organizations with extensive data may need additional time. We recommend a 1-2 week transition period for full team adoption.
Most core data can be transferred using export/import tools. However, some platform-specific features like custom automations and plugin data may need to be manually recreated in PayPal.
Yes, we recommend running both tools in parallel for 1-2 weeks. This gives your team time to adjust and ensures nothing is missed during the transition.
Both are strong options in the finance space. PayPal may offer different strengths depending on your team's needs. We recommend evaluating your specific requirements and taking advantage of any free trial before committing.

Paying for Square or PayPal? StackTidy catches them the moment you're charged — and flags them if your team stops using them.

See what StackTidy can find

Track Your Migration with StackTidy

Switching from Square to PayPal? StackTidy automatically detects both subscriptions so you know exactly when to cancel the old one.

Start Tracking